Oct 06, 2015 similarly, in new york, a shareholder has the right to examine corporate books and records upon at least five 5 days written demand for any purpose reasonably related to such persons interest as a shareholder. As common stockholders of the company, the icahn parties hereby demand to inspect and make copies of the following books and records of the company. Inspection demands adishian law group adishian law group. The boundary of proper purpose for corporate books and. Bennett, the current chief executive officer of the company. Demand for inspection of corporate books and records legal. Inspection rights for limited liability company members. These are what are known as shareholder inspection rights, and they exist under the common law and by state statute. The idea is that stockholders are entitled to know how company affair. The undersigned name of the stockholder signing this form is the holder of number of shares shares of the common stock of name of the stock and does hereby demand the opportunity to inspect, at the office of the. A recent decision by the delaware court of chancery, mehta v. Furthermore, the rcc already allows a representative of any director, trustee, stockholder or member of the corporation to request for inspection of corporate records at reasonable hours on business days, as well as demand in writing for copies of such records or excerpts from said records. Unless otherwise provided in the bylaws, such books, records and minutes may be kept outside this state. In analyzing whether emails should be produced in connection with the books and records demand, the delaware supreme court, in an opinion by chief justice strine, explained that if a company.
Books and records legal definition of books and records. Apr 12, 2019 in analyzing whether emails should be produced in connection with the books and records demand, the delaware supreme court, in an opinion by chief justice strine, explained that if a company. The right of shareholders to demand inspection of companies books and records is of course nothing new. Books and records demand delaware chancery law blog. Section 220 of the delaware general corporation law dgcl provides the means by which a stockholder can make a demand for the books and records of a delaware corporation. Section 1601 gives the shareholder or his agent or attorney the right to inspect records at the. Inspection of said information is provided if and only if the acquisition of such information is directed towards an end deemed reasonably related to the holders interest corp. The court found that plaintiff established a valid primary purpose for seeking inspection of the materials. The court rejected wests argument that corwin precluded a demand for inspection of corporate books and records. Delaware cases shed light on electronic books and records.
In addition, the delaware supreme court expressly held that in the context of a shareholder derivative action, it is a proper purpose. Implications for section 220 books and records demands. Under that provision, a shareholder need only make written demand for inspection of the books and records of the corporation stating a proper purpose. Ruling upholds shareholders right to inspect subsidiarys. A governing person director may enforce his right of access to corporate records by showing the following.
As to the derivative action argument, judge bledsoe said that obtaining corporate records to investigate and prepare a derivative action is not improper and generally encouraged. Inspection of company books and records delaware corporation law section 220 provides shareholders the right to inspect corporate records. In high river, plaintiffs sent a demand letter to defendant corporation seeking to inspect books and records in furtherance of an anticipated. Demand to inspect certain books and records of sandridge energy pursuant to section 220 of the delaware general corporation law. Texas law states that a shareholder has the right to examine corporate books and records.
As a matter of self protection, the stockholder was entitled to know how his agents were conducting the affairs of the corporation shaw v. Apr 09, 2018 as to the derivative action argument, judge bledsoe said that obtaining corporate records to investigate and prepare a derivative action is not improper and generally encouraged. Books and records means books and records of seller or any of its affiliates relating to the business or the purchased assets, including financial, corporate, operations and sales books, records, books of account, sales and purchase records, lists of suppliers and customers, business reports, plans and projections and all other documents, surveys, plans, files, records, assessments. New york consolidated laws, business corporation law bsc. The chancery court articulated that a stockholder seeking to inspect corporate books for a proper purpose, such as to investigate potential wrongdoing or mismanagement on the part of an officer or director, may demand electronic documents, including notes and emails, related to a corporate actors conduct with respect to the corporation. However, having an entrepreneurial law firm initiate the process, and draft a demand to investigate different issues than what motivated the stockholder6 will not be sufficient for a shareholder to gain access to a corporations books and records. Under section 220, a stockholder of a delaware corporation has a qualified right to inspect the companys books and records. In texas, for example, a shareholder is entitled to examine and copy the corporations relevant books, records of account, minutes, and share transfer records at a reasonable time, in person or through an agent, subject to the. The statutory right to inspect corporate books and records extends to the records of corporate subsidiaries as well, so long as a the parent corporation has possession. Minority shareholders investigation of management misconduct. The stockholders statutory right to inspect corporate. If the corporation decides that inspection is warranted, it need only make the records available for inspection. May 12, 2015 inspection of company books and records delaware corporation law section 220 provides shareholders the right to inspect corporate records. See below additional posts on books and record demands made upon delaware limited liability companies.
Secs power to demand for inspectionreproduction of. Demand to inspect certain books and records of sandridge. The statutory right to inspect corporate books and records extends to the records of corporate subsidiaries as well, so. The stockholders statutory right to inspect corporate books. Delaware courts are addressing inspection demands with regularity, providing further guidance about the scope of books and records and about what is and is not a proper purpose for a demand. Corporate shareholders have certain rights to access the books and records of a company in which they hold stock. Right of florida shareholders to inspect corporate records. Inspection of the corporations books and records shareholders also have the valuable right to inspect accounting books, records, and minutes of proceedings. Inspection, however, may be denied if the shareholder refuses to furnish an affidavit to the corporation that such.
The subsidiary would not have the right under the law applicable to it to deny the corporation access to such books and records upon demand by the corporation. Inspection, however, may be denied if the shareholder refuses to furnish an affidavit to the corporation that such inspection is not desired. Delaware books and records law is keeping up with tech. Scope of shareholder rights to corporation information. How to enforce the shareholder right to inspect corporate books and records. Delaware llc inspection rights under section 18305. In fact, fifteen years ago, very first nc business court judge tennille said that. A requesting stockholder may also demand a list of the beneficial owners of the companys stock. Nov 07, 2017 a recent decision by the delaware court of chancery, mehta v. Demand for inspection of corporate books and records. Demand for inspection of corporate books and records pdf. Jan 22, 2018 the court rejected wests argument that corwin precluded a demand for inspection of corporate books and records. The new york statute provides that a shareholder has the right to examine corporate books and records upon at least five 5 days written demand for any purpose reasonably related to such persons interest as a shareholder.
The books and records demand delaware corporate law along with all jurisdictions known to the authors provides shareholders with a qualified right to inspect a. Delaware corporation the right to inspect a corporations books and records by making a demand in the proper form and manner for a proper purpose. The shareholders right of books and records inspection under. In one of the more lengthy decisions issued in a books and records case commenced under 8 del. Section 1601 does not outline the required response to an inspection demand, although. Nc business court on shareholder inspection rights north. Latest developments in shareholder demands for books and. What is new is the increased frequency of books and records demands, often as a result of courts requirement for prospective shareholder claimants to investigate alleged misconduct of corporate executives before filing a lawsuit. Shareholder demand for inspection of records in california. Inspection of corporate books in texas yourtexasoffice. The court then analyzed found that plaintiff stated a proper purpose warranting the inspection of books and records under section 18305 and the relevant provision of the operating agreement. Stockholder demands for books and records inspections under. The shareholders right of books and records inspection.
In high river, plaintiffs sent a demand letter to defendant corporation seeking to inspect books and records in furtherance of an anticipated proxy contest, and specifically requesting books and records relating to 1 the occidentalanadarko merger, 2 defendant corporations decision to be buyer rather than seller in such transaction and. Demand for inspection of books and records of bally total. Oct 15, 2015 the new york statute provides that a shareholder has the right to examine corporate books and records upon at least five 5 days written demand for any purpose reasonably related to such persons interest as a shareholder. Oct 17, 2016 on appeal, the first department reversed the order denying reconsideration and ordered spmcs compliance with the demand for inspection, finding that petitioners have made a sufficient showing to establish their commonlaw right to inspect the books and records of spmc, 575s wholly owned subsidiary, relating to salary and compensation. The stockholders statutory right to inspect corporate books and. The longfavored approach under delaware law is for a plaintiff to file a section 220 action as an investigatory tool prior to commencing litigation to properly commence a section 220 action to inspect a corporation. Amerisourcebergen corporation, vice chancellor laster ordered amerisourcebergen corporation amerisourcebergen or the company to make available for inspection boardlevel documents formally evidencing the directors. In particular, shareholders of california corporations have rights to inspect two different sets of records. Shareholders right to inspect corporate books and records.
The statutory basis for shareholder inspection of corporate books and records is found in section 21. Stockholder demands for books and records inspections. The minority shareholders have inspection rights to corporate books and records. Over the past year, the legal landscape for booksandrecords demands under section 220 of the delaware general corporation law has continued to evolve. When the corporation refuses to comply with the directors demand for inspection. Enforcing the shareholder right to inspect books and records. Demand for inspection of corporate books and records the undersigned, is the holder of shares of the common stock of and does hereby demand the opportunity to inspect, at the office of the corporation, the books and records of the corporation, its stock ledger and the list of its shareholders. The case involved a stockholders demand under section 220 of the delaware general corporation law to obtain documents to investigate. A stockholder obviously can use counsel to seek books and records. Every business corporation shall keep complete and accurate books and records of account, minutes of the proceedings of the incorporators, shareholders and directors and a share register giving the names and addresses of all shareholders and the number and class of shares. Instead, a stockholder seeking inspection of books and records pursuant to this section must make specific and discrete identification, with rifled precision, of the documents sought, and those documents must relate to the purpose of the demand. Inspection of corporate books and records to investigate. If a corporation refuses to comply with a properly exercised demand for inspection of its books and records, a stockholder may initiate a lawsuit to compel the. Please print your completed form if you would to have a copy for your records.
The latest booksandrecords proceeding was precipitated shortly after the appellate courts ruling, when novikov made a new, written demand under bcl 624 read here, accompanied by the requisite affidavit read here, to inspect all meeting minutes, financial statements, tax returns, tenant leases, and employment. Most, if not all, state statutes provide for a mechanism by which shareholders examine corporate books and records. The rise of books and records demands under section 220 of. Apr 04, 2019 but, if a company either 1 does not comply with traditional corporate formalities, i. On appeal, the first department reversed the order denying reconsideration and ordered spmcs compliance with the demand for inspection, finding that petitioners have made a sufficient showing to establish their commonlaw right to inspect the books and records of spmc, 575s wholly owned subsidiary, relating to salary and compensation.
1362 13 113 958 1131 249 1332 167 1132 1366 226 132 262 460 1512 1634 662 27 1474 1113 120 225 1366 773 578 56 194 830 641 225 1465 713